Sheetz’s new “gourmet donuts” had some winners and a clear loser

He plays

Who does not love a great cake? After all, defining what constitutes a “good” donut will be troublesome, however most individuals would agree that gasoline stations aren’t recognized for serving the most effective of those desserts. Sheetz is making an attempt to vary that.

The comfort retailer large not too long ago entered new territory by launching a line of grab-and-go “gourmand muffins.” An assortment of eight new sugary treats are baked contemporary day by day and will be discovered in any respect Sheetz areas.

However are they good? YDR reporters Angel Albring and Lena Tzivekis went out to style take a look at the muffins, and located that some had been higher than others — with a transparent winner standing out above the remainder.

Let’s begin with my least favourite of the eight muffins:

Galaxy vanilla

From the angel: Vanilla Galaxy has “multi-colored swirls of vanilla cream and crunchy gold stars,” based on a press launch Sheetz shared concerning the new lineup, and we knew it was going to be unhealthy simply by it. One thing about blue and purple swirls on an hours-old cake does not attraction to the senses, however we tried it.

It was as unhealthy because it appeared.

I’ve a really distinct reminiscence of being somewhat lady in Louisiana and coloring in a coloring e book exterior on a sizzling day. The crayons melted, and by some means, I acquired yellow in my mouth. These donuts style like this crayon.

test it out: Restaurant inspection: Ice machine comprises “black substance and sticky residue”

Coconut chocolate

From the angel: I could also be biased about this, as a result of I feel the odor of coconut is healthier than the flavour, however the chocolate coconut donut, with chocolate frosting, caramel, toasted coconut, chocolate, and shortbread bits, was extra like a greenback retailer snack cake than a “gourmand” deal with.

The chocolate had a plastic style, was a bit candy, and the dough was very dry.

Cookies n cream

From Lina: In accordance with Sheetz, Cookies N Cream consists of blended cookies and cream and chocolate and vanilla cookie sandwich items. These donuts weren’t bursting with taste, however they weren’t overly candy. It wasn’t nice, nevertheless it wasn’t unhealthy by any means.

Traditional glazed

From Lina: Traditional Glazed is strictly what you’d anticipate from a medium sized glazed cake. The fried dough is nice and tender, glazed with syrup, however not overly candy. It reminded us of a fast evening out.

Strawberry pie

From the angel: The Strawberry Shortcake donut has strawberry icing, pink and white flavors, and candy strawberry clusters, and it is rather well achieved.

It reminded us of Fruity Pebbles as a result of the strawberry glaze has a lemon zest to it, making it each tart and candy.

Extra in meals: The very best ice cream retailers in York County, based on locals. Want to make an inventory?

Peanut butter cup

From Lina: Peanut butter and chocolate are at all times a successful mixture. These donuts have a wealthy peanut butter topping, chocolate drizzle, and chopped peanut butter cups.

One chew of our Peanut Butter Cup Donut makes you’re feeling such as you’re consuming a peanut butter cup dessert. The peanut butter frosting was wealthy and barely salty, and the chocolate drizzle added a pleasant steadiness of sweetness. The chopped peanut butter cups on high had been chewy and added the right texture.

Brownie turtle

From Lina: These Brownie Turtle Donuts characteristic a candy caramel topping, blended brownie items, pecans, and crunchy gold stars. This was easy and moist, and the caramel was not overly candy, however had a wealthy taste with an espresso be aware from the chocolate combination. The blended brownie bits and candied pecan items on high additionally added a scrumptious texture.

I am unable to say sufficient nice issues about this donut. Please go get one now, you’ll thank me later.

Apple pie

From the Gospel of our guardian: Our favourite was the apple pie. This was excellent for fall with a heat cup of espresso. The pie has candy and tangy bits of apple mixed with wealthy, comfortable dough and a touch of cinnamon to make you dream of crisp leaves and funky breezes.

Extra in native meals: Greatest pizza in York County? Under are native eating places with excessive scores on Yelp


  • First: Apple Competition Pie
  • Second: Turtle brownie
  • Third: Peanut butter cup
  • Fourth: strawberry cake
  • Fifth: Traditional glass
  • Sixth: Cookies n Cream
  • Seventh: Coconut chocolate
  • Eighth: Galaxy Vanilla

In case you determine to strive any of those scrumptious new muffins, tell us what you suppose. You’ll be able to electronic mail Angel at Or Lina in

You may also like...

Leave a Reply